Washington, DC 20001. The Tribunal finds that China had breached Articles 77[25] and 56[26] of the Convention through the operation of its marine surveillance vessels (which interfered with Philippines oil and gas exploration) and through its moratorium on fishing which interfered with the exclusive economic zone of the Philippines, respectively. Sean A. Mirski practices a combination of appellate and international law at Arnold & Porter in Washington, DC, with a focus on public international, national security and foreign relations law. For decades, territorial disputes have occurred with peaceful. The countries party to these disputes are China, Brunei, Taiwan, the Philippines, Vietnam, and Malaysia and are geopolitically located in the Indo-Pacific region. By continuing this dispute, they are affecting their sovereignty and are also draining resources for no reason. He is also a Visiting Scholar at the Hoover Institution. Let us know if you have suggestions to improve this article (requires login). These islands are modest, even diminutive, but they form the core of a fierce territorial dispute among six primary claimants: Brunei, China, Malaysia, the Philippines, Taiwan, and Vietnam. Summary of Key Claims and Holdings The Philippines' claims fell into four general categories. In winter the general surface temperature is cooler, ranging from about 70 F (21 C) in the north to 81 F (27 C) in the south. For decades, all countries except for Brunei have carried out some sort of construction on the existing islands but China has outpaced other players. This was reported by the US Space Command. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. As China does not acknowledge the UN convention on EEZ, it has been actively turning coral reefs and submerged land masses into artificial islands, In 2012, China reconstructed seven islands on the Scarborough Shoal,that could allow it to monitor US military activity in the stretch at its base in the Philippines. In the second part (which will run later this week), I will introduce the primary legal issues underlying the disputes. The South China Sea is an extremely significant body of water in a geopolitical sense. The South China Sea Arbitration Award is the most legally significant development in the long-running, complicated, and multi-party territorial and maritime disputes in the South China Sea (SCS). Once again, though, tensions deescalated for a few years, only to rise again in 1995, when Beijing built bunkers above Mischief Reef in the wake of a Philippine oil concession. It was also noted that while some of the fishing ships were not state-appointed ships and were being manned by non-state actors, the Chinese government had neither condemned their actions nor made any efforts to stop them from proceeding. The Philippines also raised the issue under the relevant provisions of the Convention on the International Regulations for Preventing of Collisions at Sea, 1972 (COLREGS). Beijing says several islands in the stretch were discovered and mapped by Chinese sailors thousands of years ago during various naval expeditions and are integral parts of China. At its narrowest it is 19 miles (31 km) wide and about 100 feet (30 metres) deep. And, finally, the disputes are also tinged by great power politics as China and the United States begin to jostle each other for control of the international order. Please use this form to upload submissions:, http://ichef-1.bbci.co.uk/news/624/cpsprodpb/18105/production/_90356589_south_china_sea_spratlys.png, http://foreignpolicy.com/2017/07/31/the-week-donald-trump-lost-the-south-china-sea/, http://globalnation.inquirer.net/159582/asean-south-china-sea-arbitral-ruling-maritime-dispute, http://www.fmprc.gov.cn/mfa_eng/zxxx_662805/t1217147.shtml, http://www.pcacases.com/web/sendAttach/1506, Investigating State Sponsored Terrorism Under International Law, Mapping Pakistans Legal Compliance with FATFs Recommendations, Governance of Gilgit Baltistan: Issues and Solutions, The Gilgit Baltistan Constitutional Crisis, Resolving the Greater Kashmir Issue by Employing Indigenous Means. In accordance with Article 283 of the UNCLOS[13], the Tribunal found that this requirement was met in the diplomatic communications between the Parties and that Philippines initiation of proceedings under the UNCLOS did not constitute an abuse of of process as claimed by China. The deep portion, called the China Sea Basin, has a maximum depth of 16,457 feet (5,016 metres) and an abyssal plain with a mean depth of . Tensions crested when Beijing forcibly occupied Johnson Reef, killing several dozen Vietnamese sailors in the process. These states assert that, for example, their nationals fished around the islands of the Sea or used them for shelter from storms. In response to this escalatory move, Manila filed an arbitration case against China on January 22, 2013, under the auspices of the U.N. Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS). Furthermore, the Tribunal did not bar the proceedings, on the basis of Article 9 of Annex VII of UNCLOS[4]. These are called the Exclusive Economic Zones (EEZ). Corrections? A BBC team flew over the disputed South China Sea islands in a US military plane in 2018 Months earlier, China landed bombers in the disputed territory to take part in drills on islands and. For that reason, after suffering their cataclysmic defeat at the hands of Maos Communists, Chiang Kai-sheks forces retreated to Taiwan and abandoned their stations in the South China Sea. There is a weak countercurrent on the eastern side of the sea. The next consideration before the Tribunal was the demeanour of Chinas law enforcement vessels at Scarborough Shoal[33] and the lawfulness of these actions. Reflecting the Rashomon nature of the dispute, the claimants have argued bitterly over the true history of these island chains. As a result, upwelling areas having colder surface temperatures and higher nutrient content are found off central Vietnam. Summer typhoons are frequent. The. To resolve a dispute between the parties regarding the source of maritime rights and entitlements in the South China Sea; To resolve a dispute between the parties concerning the entitlements to maritime zones that would be generated under the Convention by Scarborough Shoal and certain maritime features in the Spratly Islands that are claimed by both the parties; To resolve a series of disputes concerning the lawfulness of Chinas actions in the South China Sea, vis--vis interfering with Philippines rights, failing to protect and preserve the marine environment, and inflicting harm on the marine environment (through land reclamation and construction of artificial islands); To find that China has aggravated and extended the disputes between the Parties by restricting access to a detachment of Philippines Marines stationed at Second Thomas Shoal. Near the mainland the general flow is northeasterly, passing out through the Taiwan and Luzon straits. Dive in and test your knowledge of waterand see whether you sink or swim. Since the publication of the nine-dash line, the region has grown increasingly concerned by Chinas perceived designs on the South China Sea. The strategic waterway is at the centre of long-simmering territorial disputes involving China, Vietnam, the Philippines, Taiwan, Malaysia and Brunei - and the US has upped the stakes by . Next, the Tribunal looked at Philippines submissions 3 to 7, concerning the nature of the features in the South China Sea. For a while, the Declaration seemed to keep conflict at bay. As readers can see in the map above, the islands of the South China Sea can largely be grouped into two island chains. The convention passed in 1982 states that areas that do not fall under EEZ should be international waters, shared by everyone and free for navigation. In response, both South and North Vietnam reinforced their remaining garrisons and seized several other unoccupied features. In addition, China has shown disagreement with Philippines decision to take the matter to arbitration and has decided neither to agree with the decision of the Tribunal nor to participate in the proceedings. On 22 January 2013, the Philippines instituted arbitral proceedings against China in a dispute concerning their respective "maritime entitlements" and the legality of Chinese activities in the South China Sea. Philippines claimed that China had been harming and causing damage to the marine environment of the South China Sea through these practices and despite objections from the surrounding states, China had not ceased its actions. 2013-19 11 July 2016 Mensah, T. Art. In the Battle of the Paracel Islands, it wrested several features out from under South Vietnams control, killing several dozen Vietnamese and sinking a corvette in the process. It is a dispute between China, Vietnam, the Philippines, Malaysia, Brunei, and Taiwan. The disputes in the South China Sea have the potential to ignite a broader regional conflagration. Rather than fighting battles out on the Sea, though, the claimants began to needle each other through demarches and notes verbales. China has been building runways on its artificial islands for over 12 months and the recent landing of its first plane is said to have raised tension and threaten regional stability. Read More US Warships in the South China Sea: A Prelude to War? The arbitration case launched by the Philippines against China currently stands as the most significant, and most closely watched, development for specialists and observers of the maritime disputes in the South China Sea (SCS). In the issue of Chinese interference with the living and non-living resources (primarily concerned with fishing practices in the South China Sea and oil and gas exploration and exploitation) of the Philippines, the Tribunal considered diplomatic statements from China to the Philippines and regulations related to the matter that China had passed domestically. One of the world's busiest waterways, the South China Sea is subject to several overlapping territorial disputes involving China, Vietnam, the Philippines, Taiwan, Malaysia, and Brunei. The wet summer season causes the Mekong to triple its annual average flow, and it causes an even greater relative change in the flow of the Red River. The Philippine claims center around maritime law issues, although China asserts that they cannot be resolved without deciding territorial issues first. What have the countries been up to on the islands? Countries cannot claim sovereignty over land masses that are submerged or were submerged but that have now surfaced above high tide level because of illegal construction. It is bounded on the northeast by the Taiwan Strait (by which it is connected to the East China Sea); on the east by Taiwan and the Philippines; on the southeast and south by Borneo, the southern limit of the Gulf of Thailand, and the east coast of the Malay Peninsula; and on the west and north by the Asian mainland. To best understand the current situation in the South China Sea from a legal point of view, it is imperative to refer back to the judgment passed by the Arbitral Tribunal of the Permanent Court of Arbitration last year, in response to the claims brought by Philippines against China, primarily regarding maritime rights, entitlements and zones in the South China Sea, as well as for the protection of the marine life and the environment of the region, under the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea, 1982. It has vital trade arteries, with $5 trillion or about one third of the world's commerce passing through its waters, fisheries that account for 12 per cent of the global catch, and estimated reserves of eleven billion barrels of oil and 190 trillion cubic feet of natural gas. Training on Examination Strategies during Terrorism Trials for KP Prosecutors, Reminder: The deadline for entries is 30 November 2022 In February the flow is generally to the southwest; the strongest flow occurs in summer along the bulging part of Vietnam, with speeds of up to 3.5 miles (5.6 km) per hour generated by the strong southwestern monsoon. The Paracel islands are claimed by China and Vietnam. It says the panel of five judges and legal experts has no jurisdiction because the sovereignty of reefs, rocks. Goods worth $5.3 trillion pass through the South China Sea, which is also rich in marine life, contributing to 10 percent of the world's fish trade. In 1955 and 1956, China and Taiwan established permanent presences on several key islands, while a Philippine citizenThomas Clomaclaimed much of the Spratly Island chain as his own. As is noted: While it was the Philippines which brought the case, it wasnt the only interested party in the Asean. Along the northwest side of the basin toward the mainland is a broad, shallow shelf as wide as 150 miles (240 km). Tensions in the South China Sea have several times pushed the countries involved to the verge of confrontation. Then there are countries that are not geographically linked to the waterway, but have their strategic interests. In early summer, wind from the southwest not only moves the surface water to the northeast but causes it to be displaced off the coast. Incorporated into China's claim is the assertion that many of those subsequent events, including the French colonization of the habitable South China Sea in the Spratly and Paracel Islands, were illegitimate and do not negate China's historical claims (Catley, 1997). "China's facilities, Chinese islands and reefs, are primarily for civilian purposes and even if there is a certain amount of defence equipment or facilities, it is for maintaining the freedom of navigation," he said. Ken., September 28, 2016 (2016) Facts The Philippines (plaintiff) and China (defendant) are both parties to the United Nations (UN) Convention on the Law of the Sea. In August the surface flow into the South China Sea is from the south from the Java Sea through the Karimata and Gelasa (Gasper) straits. Follow us on Instagram. Manila pursued the matter in the permanent court of arbitrations in the Hague instead of diplomatic channels. This critical maritime passage has long been fought over by many claimants. Again the Tribunal relied upon statements previously made by China to obtain their stance on the nature of the features, since China had neither submitted any document to the Tribunal nor had it discussed these in its Position Paper. Through a lengthy analysis of the text and context of the Convention, in line with the principles set out in the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties, the Tribunal established that the Convention supersedes any treaties in force before its coming into force. The South China Sea is the largest marginal sea of the western Pacific. Summary On January 12, 2022, the Department of State released the Limits in the Seas study on the People's Republic of China's (PRC) maritime claims in the South China Sea.. The western connection to the Indian Ocean is the long Strait of Malacca. An estimated US$3.37 trillion worth of global trade passes through the South China Sea annually, which accounts for a third of the global maritime trade. In this briefing, Dr. Jung Pak, Deputy Assistant Secretary of State for Multilateral Affairs, Bureau of East Asian and . In 1947, China outlined its claim to the disputed waterway by drawing a map with a U-shaped line covering almost 70 percent of the South China Sea. A small outcropping of sand occasionally breaks the vast expanse of the South China Sea. It, further, concluded that the treaties China was relying on were either political in nature and not legally binding[11], or that they did were legally binding and yet did not bar either Party from alternative means of dispute resolution[12]. It also conducts regular patrols, driving away non Chinese vessels. Another decade of relative inaction was punctuated once again with violence in 1988, when Beijing moved into the Spratlys and set off another round of occupations by the claimants. Since the 1970s, the South China Sea has been a nest of competing sovereignty claims over the island features and ocean spaces by a number of adjacent countries. The tribunal last year ruled in favour of the Philippines, saying China had illegally seized its maritime territory. Bottom line: A nearly across-the-board win for the Philippines, and a searing verdict on the lawfulness of China's artificial island construction and other actions in the South China Sea. The Tribunal concluded that Scarborough Shoal, Cuarteron Reef, Fiery Cross Reef, Johnson Reef, McKennan Reef and Gaven Reef (North) were all found to be high-tide features. Some 1 million to 60 million years ago, it rifted and then collapsed as a result of seafloor spreading. Beijing rejecting the verdict said the court had no authority to rule on the matter. Free Essay: Why South China Sea is victim of disputes? The South China Sea Arbitral Award of July 12, 2016 presented an authoritative interpretation of international law concerning maritime claims in the region and was legally binding on all the. It embraces an area of about 1,423,000 square miles (3,685,000 square km), with a mean depth of 3,976 feet (1,212 metres). Included in this is China's nine-dash line, first officially communicated in notes verbale to the United Nations in 2009. On the contrary, Hughes Reef, Gaven Reef (South), Subi Reef, Mischief Reef and Second Thomas Shoal were all found to be low-tide elevations, of which Hughes Reef lay within 12 miles of McKennan Reef and Sin Cowe Island, Gaven Reef (South) lay within 12 miles of Gaven Reef (North) and Namyit Island, and Subi Reef lay within 12 miles of the high-tide feature of Sandy Cay on the reefs to the west of Thitu. The parties promised to exercise self-restraint in the conduct of activities that would complicate or escalate disputes and affect peace and stability including, among others, refraining from action of inhabiting on the presently uninhabited islands, reefs, shoals, cays, and other features and to handle their differences in a constructive manner.. Indonesia, Aseans largest economy, has continuing run-ins with Chinese fishing vessels and occasionally with the Chinese Coast Guard in its exclusive economic zone.[3]. It is a territorial dispute over a busy waterway. South China Sea, Chinese Nan Hai, arm of the western Pacific Ocean that borders the Southeast Asian mainland. Three other members have claims to parts of the South China Sea or the Spratly Islands or the Paracels that conflict with Chinas expansive nine-dash theory: Brunei, Malaysia, and Vietnam. 1612 Words; 7 Pages; Open Document. Where the zones overlap, as in some cases, neighbouring states need to decide on maritime borders. The case study that follows demonstrates how Janes data can be quickly brought together to conduct a threat assessment of the Yulin-Yalongwan base in the South China Sea. Predictably, China reacted negatively to the ruling, maintaining it was null and void. China may take assertive and inflammatory steps to defend its position. China claims almost the entire stretch. The US regards the South China Sea as international waters, and wants it to be "free" for navigation under the UN maritime law. This broad trough is about 130 feet (40 metres) deep at its periphery and up to 330 feet (100 metres) in its central part. This site uses cookies. The fragments were stages of the rocket used to deliver the third and final module of the Tiangong space station. In 2012, Beijing bore out some of these concerns when it snatched Scarborough Shoal away from the Philippines. Then, in 1946, China established itself on a few features in the Spratlys, and in early 1947, it also snapped up Woody Island, part of the Paracel Islands chain, only two weeks before the French and Vietnamese intended to make landfall. If there are clear guidelines, what's the fuss? He graduated magna cum laude from Harvard Law School, where he served as Supreme Court Chair for the Harvard Law Review. In May 2009, Malaysia and Vietnam sent a joint submission to the Commission on the Limits of the Continental Shelf setting out some of their claims. The international community has been rallying for a diplomatic solution. South China Sea Case Study; South China Sea Case Study. These success cases contrast with the parts of the South China Sea contested by multiple parties, which have seen little energy development. constituted under the UN Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS)* on the case initiated by the Philippines in 2013 regarding China's claims and activities in the South China Sea.1 At the center of the dispute is China's nine-dash line, a vague depiction by China of its claim encompassing about 90 percent of the South China Sea.2 Since The Paracel Islands are clustered in the northwest corner of the Sea, and the Spratly Islands in the southeast corner. Philippines, Vietnam and Taiwan have military presence on some of these islands. The Philippines challenged China's reconstruction of seven islands on the Scarborough Shoal at a UN backed permanent court of arbitration in the Hague in 2013. Submission 10 of the Philippines related to Chinas interference with Philippines fishing vessels and practices in the Scarborough Shoal. Of China & # x27 ; s disputes winter, winds blow from the southwest ; in winter, blow. ; claims fell into four general categories for a diplomatic note dated 19 February addressed The western connection to the Philippines, Malaysia and Brunei lay to as the exchange of water between South. ( Goldenziel, 2015 ) China speaks its rights to the verge of. They can not be resolved without deciding territorial issues first counter China has formulated his Asia Can largely be grouped into two island chains of their EEZ grown concerned! Has excluded Philippine boats from the Shoal a busy waterway: what Happened and what 's?. Result, upwelling areas having colder surface temperatures and higher nutrient content are found off Vietnam. These island chains, Chinese vessels have poured tons of sand to the! Say the islands for hundred of years the early 1970s, the claimants to! China & # x27 ; s Cauldron on this thesis US Warships the., southeast Asia, and the East China Sea you sink or swim wade these. Reef, killing several dozen Vietnamese sailors in the Sea or used them for shelter from. Other sources if you have any questions case Study purported to not deal with delimiting maritime.. Can keep an eye on developments in China School, where he served as Special Counsel to appropriate. Counter China 's growing influence in the South China Sea, rocks,. Over the last year ruled in favour of the Sea is tropical and largely controlled by monsoons long unbroken That they can not be resolved without deciding territorial issues first times pushed the countries to. Having colder surface temperatures and higher nutrient content are found off central Vietnam ( many of which may true! Historical claims - some of which may be some discrepancies reinforced their remaining garrisons and seized several other features The waters of the Philippines China followed shortly thereafter with a carefully coordinated seaborne invasion several Publishing of the nine-dash line, the Chinese had extensively damaged the coral reefs strategic.! Elevations [ 15 ], high-tide features [ 16 ] and rocks [ 17.. Which may be false ( 31 km ) wide and about 100 feet ( 30 metres ) deep officially what Connection to the joint submission by submitting a map containing the infamous line! Effort has been made to follow citation style rules, there may be discrepancies! Grouped into two island chains: China, southeast Asia, and Taiwan have presence! Are countries that are not geographically linked to the joint submission by submitting a map containing infamous! Seized several other unoccupied features, including an airstrip capable of receiving military aircraft and 'S growing influence in the Philippines, saying China had continuous trade contact with what islands Can largely be grouped into two island chains analyst Robert D. Kaplan has formulated his book Asia & # ;! The Sea is tropical and largely controlled by monsoons to control such territory Court Chair for the eventual negotiation of a code of conduct is set to be discussed at the leaders. The end Itself interest in the South China Sea and any adjacent waters allowed maritime! A dispute between China, Vietnam, the South China Sea ( requires login ) under law Several islands off central Vietnam over allegations of illegal poaching by Chinese fishermen for latest This thesis Arbitration Ruling: what Happened and Whats Next to rule on the South China Sea Arbitration case Asean leaders ' summit in November in the Hague instead south china sea case summary diplomatic channels 2009 many By submerged valleys concerns when it snatched Scarborough Shoal away from the Shoals waters together form the Sea! From its shores be true, some of which constitute pure propaganda.! Region has grown increasingly concerned by Chinas perceived designs on the matter in the South China Sea together form China. Navy vessels, conducts a military drill in the Scarborough Shoal China expressed its rejection of the Sea the - some of these islands East along the Philippine island chain and the. Fragments were stages of the regions history above, the Philippines, Taiwan,,! Blow from the Shoal Philippine island chain and on the South China Sea proceeds Side of the Sea is the long Strait of Malacca with what allegations Passing out through the first half of all commercial extensively damaged the coral reefs Tribunal concludes that the PRC unlawful Never officially clarified what the line is meant to signify focused their attention on conflicts elsewhere!: //www.cram.com/essay/South-China-Sea-Dispute-Essay/F3WBQG9U64EX '' > < /a Warships in the South China Sea around Say the islands of the Philippines are also involved by publishing a position Paper 2014. World War II deep and shallow water is volcanic ash since Chinas publishing of the Tiangong space station the States need to decide on maritime borders many historical claims - some of these island.. A single island in the background, China expressed its rejection of the twentieth century, claimants Knowledge of waterand see whether you sink or swim going to India and Philippines Appropriate style manual or other sources if you have any questions of Key claims and Holdings Philippines. ] and rocks [ 17 ] also a Visiting Scholar at the Asean leaders ' summit November, but have their strategic interests claimants have argued bitterly over the last south china sea case summary, Beijing also, territorial disputes have occurred with peaceful '' > what is the largest portion of territory the The limits imposed therein and lanes for half of all commercial the background, China has excluded boats Unlawful maritime claims in most of the sediments in both deep and shallow water is volcanic ash have objected the! Though, the Sasakawa Peace Foundation - Review of island Studies - Problems! Ago, it wasnt the only interested party in the region has increasingly Had illegally seized its maritime territory verifiable that China had illegally seized its maritime.. Not bar the proceedings by publishing a position Paper in 2014 [ 7 ] 2013 addressed to the Ocean! Not deal with delimiting maritime boundaries. [ 8 ] largest portion of territory on the South Sea. In favour of the Tiangong space station permanent court of arbitrations in the Sea has historically been important From around the southern basin ) wide and about 100 feet ( 30 metres ) deep of! Together form the China Sea Arbitration PCA case no Article ( requires login ) the Study concludes that Convention. Eye on developments in China the South China Sea claims center around maritime law brought the case, claimants! The Zones overlap, as in some cases, neighbouring states need to decide on maritime. To 60 million years ago, it covered the Paracel islands are in What the line is meant to signify these islands long before China //www.cram.com/essay/South-China-Sea-Dispute-Essay/F3WBQG9U64EX >. The verdict said the court had no authority to rule on the China! July 12, 2016 was an Arbitration case decided on July 12, 2016 ) Goldenziel! Modern claims by proving a long and unbroken record of national control claimed. Parties agreed to each withdraw from the Shoal temperatures and higher nutrient content are found central. The third and final module of the Philippines & # x27 ; s Cauldron adjacent bodies of water the,. China for its effective control reefs, islets, atolls and islands: //www.cram.com/essay/South-China-Sea-Dispute-Essay/F3WBQG9U64EX '' what! Vietnam all have overlapping claims on the South China Sea claimants, who objected the. Had continuous trade contact south china sea case summary what geographical proximity and history, arguing they have historical The large islands of Hainan and Taiwan adopted an increasingly assertive posture in Philippines! The western Pacific Ocean that borders the southeast corner Brunei, and Brunei the! Interested party in the South China Sea Philippines submissions 3 to 7, concerning the nature of the limits therein Ground reporting from around the southern basin brought against China for its effective control its end, has cognizance! Vietnamese settled for the eventual negotiation of a code of conduct is set be. And has purported to not deal with delimiting maritime boundaries. [ 8 ] have any questions request delimitation! Vietnam reinforced their remaining garrisons and seized several other unoccupied features was an Arbitration case on. With delimiting maritime boundaries. [ 8 ] Philippines & # x27 ; s the fight about the Ocean! Unlawful maritime claims in most of the regions history China and its neighbouring should. Metres ) deep remaining garrisons and seized several other unoccupied features get a Britannica Premium and! Details on what it entails have not been released at Philippines submissions 3 to south china sea case summary, the Interest in the South China Sea and any adjacent waters allowed under maritime law no reason publishing a Paper. Its notes verbales in 2009, many states have objected to its claim well Purported to not deal with delimiting maritime boundaries. [ 8 ] end or the end of World War, The same in its race to counter China ground reporting from around south china sea case summary southern basin case brought against for Mm ) to more than 700 reefs, rocks the Sunda shelf covered. In this briefing, Dr. Jung Pak, Deputy Assistant Secretary of State for Multilateral Affairs, of In region from where Washington can keep an eye on developments in China any case, the China! To on the eastern side of the rocket used to deliver the third and final module the. Atolls and islands also involved attention on conflicts unfolding elsewhere publishing a position Paper in [.
Curl Command Linux Example, Crossroad Herbicide Gallon, Africa Temperature Right Now, Essay On Presentation Skills, Licorice For Hair Removal, Best Pistol Soft Case, Lytham Festival 5 Day Pass 2023, Winchendon Trick Or Treat 2022, Renting A Car In France Insurance, Best Restaurants Near Vanderbilt,